I cannot AirPlay both video and audio (from iMac and iPhone 5) to First-Gen Apple TV?

Kadelic

Genius
Gold
Jan 4, 2010
4,957
1,609
113
Dallas, TX
I honestly don't know if that's your only option, but I think it is. If you're going to upgrade it might as well be to the ATV3.
 

Europa

Moderator
Senior Moderator
Dec 12, 2008
28,453
5,404
113
Utah
Yeah, you'll need to upgrade to an ATV2 or 3. AirPlay isn't compatible with the ATV1.