One thing I dislike a/b the bumper is that it hides that pretty metal band (antenna) around the outside. Although I guess anything but a clear case, invisishield of some sort or a nakey phone would do that, too.
My girlfriend has a orange incase case for her 3GS and it looks absolutely disgusting after only 4 months. It's got the same exact rubber as my bumper so I'm sorry to say that your white bumper is going to look like a horses sphincter in a few short months.
I've had the orange incase slider on my 3G for a year now and it still looks great.
My sister got basically the same orange incase a little while after I got mine. I saw hers about a week ago and it didn't look nearly as good as mine, but I don't think she's remotely careful with it. Heck, I know she dropped her whole phone in some sweet potatoes last Thanksgiving. She goes out a lot and I'm sure just throws it in her purse with who knows what.
Not that I think the bumper is exactly the same as the incase anyway, but I can say that my incase still looks great after a year.
The brand is Clear Coat and I'm pretty sure I got it for $24.99 + installation, I don't remember the total. But no orange peel and the fingerprints and face oil is very minimal. I actually didn't even notice until you asked and I looked at my phone, lol.
I just ordered the black buMper since I don't have an Apple store within hrs it ships between July 5th and 14th everything else is backordered tell the 16th I'm using a 2 piece incipico from AT&T a pretty flexible soft plastic and then another slim silicone part it's a 2 piece case. Very nice comes with two silicone replacements was 30 even
i have this case... posted a pic of it back on like page 2 or 3
its a good case.. but it adds some thickness. makes it about the same thickness as a 3gs.
i liked the case but disliked how it hid all the beauty of the phone